Seasoned all-rounder Dwayne Bravo believes West Indies selectors erred by overlooking experienced middle order batsman Marlon Samuels for the upcoming ICC World Cup.
The 38-year-old Samuels, a veteran of 207 One-Day Internationals, was a notable omission when the Robert Haynes-led selection panel announced their 15-man squad for the May 30 to July 14 showpiece last month.
More surprisingly, Samuels was not included on the 10-man reserve list announced last week.
“Marlon Samuels is a surprise. I think Marlon Samuels was there with the team throughout the playoffs (World Cup qualifiers) and in series after the team had qualified so him being left out was a surprise to me,” Bravo said in an interview on i95.5FM on Thursday.
“They should have picked him. Marlon should have been in the squad. Being there throughout the playoffs, being an experienced guy in the middle – he should be there.
“Whether or not they start him [in the final XI] but I think he has done enough to be in the 15-man squad to go to England. It would have been his last World Cup.”
Samuels helped West Indies secure their World Cup berth last March in Zimbabwe, scoring 231 runs an average of 33, as the Caribbean reached the finals of the qualifying tournament.
However, he struggled on tours of India and Bangladesh later that year, averaging just 16 in eight matches with a highest score of 26, and was not a part of the squad which drew 2-2 in a five-match series with England in the Caribbean earlier this year.
Overall, he has nearly 6 000 ODI runs at an average of 32 with 10 hundreds, and has long been regarded as a match-winner, especially in tournament finals.
Bravo said only injury could have kept Samuels out of the World Cup side.
“I don’t know what was the thinking of the selectors obviously with guys like (Shimron) Hetmyer and Shai Hope in the side. Maybe he (Samuels) is not fit, I don’t know. Maybe something is wrong with him, who knows.” Bravo mused.
West Indies retained the core of the squad from the England series which meant there was also no room for all-rounder Rovman Powell who captained the side on the tour of Bangladesh last December when Jason Holder was ruled out through injury.
Powell, too, was part of the West Indies qualifying campaign, averaging 44 and hitting his maiden ODI hundred – 101 against Ireland.
Bravo said the Jamaican’s exclusion raised questions over the selection process.
“Rovman Powell also missed out who had a good qualifying campaign, he was the captain in the Bangladesh series and then now totally out of the team,” he pointed out.
“Sometimes you just have to question certain decisions. Players get picked on merit but sometimes the way how you pick and drop players, sometimes you have to question some of these decisions.”
Bravo was named on the reserve list for the World Cup but said there was no discontentment with not being included in the final squad.
“I won’t say I’m disappointed because I haven’t played for West Indies in over four years, especially in 50-over cricket, and when the opportunity came up and there was a slight chance of me being there in the World Cup, I had a chat with the captain Jason Holder and letting him know I could be available if the opportunity is there,” Bravo explained.
“He said as much as he would love to have me in the setup, it would be unfair to the other guys who were there, which I accept also because again I haven’t played for four years and was already retired.”
West Indies are in England preparing for the World Cup where they face Pakistan in their opening match at Trent Bridge in Nottingham next week Friday.